I've been married for 20 years and my chief bridesmaid is someone I'm no longer in touch with. To be honest, we'd started to drift apart even before I got married but I still had her as my chief bridesmaid which I do regret. Don't get me wrong, we were still friends and she'd never done anything wrong. But our ' best friendship' had run it's course and with hindsight, I should have given that role to someone else. My cousin would have been an ideal choice. I think I gave her that role as we promised each other when we were much younger that we would be each other's chief bridesmaids and godmothers to each others kids. So due to some silly childhood promise, I continued to go along with it. Though thankfully I didn't ask her to be my children's godmother and I have a feeling she would have refused if I'd asked her anyway. I haven't spoken to her in maybe fifteen years and I don't know where she is today. But my point is if you really feel that this isn't the person you want following you down the aisle, then ask someone else. Don't be bound by obligation. I think Green Diamante said it best - you were close when you were her bridesmaid, but you're not so close now. So if I were you, I'd ask the person I really want as my chief bridesmaid. And please don't feel guilty about it!